Page Heading
An Epilogue to the Kelo Case
Tuesday, September 20, 2011 4:35 pm | By J. Michael Wahlen

Yesterday, Reason Magazine featured a great article that chronicles a new twist in the famous Kelo vs. New London case. This landmark case radically increased the size of government under the eminent domain clause by forcing Susette Kelo to leave her house so that the City of New London could use the land for “economic development” in 2005.

The new twist comes from a story recounted by a journalist and author Jeff Benedict. Benedict recounts a recent book reading of The Little Pink House (written on the Kelo case) in which Justice Richard N. Palmer, one of the 4 judges who voted against Kelo on the Connecticut Supreme Court was present. After the reading, Palmer came up to Susette Kelo and apologized. He explained to her that if he had known what New London would do with the land, he would have ruled differently.

While this change in opinion at the time would have swayed the 4-3 margin and allowed Susette to keep her home, it does not change the circumstances now. Kelo was ultimately forced to leave her “little pink house” which was razed for “economic development” that never came . As Reason notes, Justice Palmer, among others, should be sorry.

While Palmer’s apology doesn’t change the situation, it does go a long way to show the folly in taking property rights away from people. Hopefully we can all learn the lesson of Justice Palmer; that the property rights of citizens should be held sacred, and should not be sacrificed to the government in the name of economic development, or corporate gain.

Permalink | Comments

Justice Palmer should be ashamed of himself. He was in a position of responsibility, and he failed miserably.
Jame Drouin / Houston, Texas September 21, 2011 21:22 am

Always a good job right here. Keep rolling on trhoguh.
Keydren / kMIPGoACsWKDGxDa October 20, 2011 20:22 pm

Heck of a job there, it aboslutley helps me out.
Doll / FZDqYoXtyhfEV October 29, 2011 29:18 am

I just love this! Let's get them all--especially Ginsburg. I hope they at least keep this up long enough to get a lot more atnottien. Face it, the average American doesn't even know there was a bone-headed decision.
Levandovschi / pJg6NEjXx9 October 24, 2015 24:45 pm

Add a comment
Your email address will not be displayed but will be added to our contact database. If you do not wish us to contact you, please leave that field blank.
Name:     Comment: